Quick Summary: Why use a staffing agency? Staffing agencies speed up hiring, connect you with top talent, reduce hiring risks, and cut costs by handling sourcing, screening, and onboarding—helping businesses fill roles efficiently.

---

Hiring the right employees is one of the most critical challenges businesses face. The process can be time-consuming, costly, and uncertain, leaving companies struggling to fill key roles. That’s why many businesses turn to staffing agencies to streamline hiring, access top talent, and reduce recruitment risks.

At Amtec, we’ve been helping companies find high-quality employees for over 65 years. As a staffing agency ourselves, we understand both the benefits and considerations of using staffing firms. This article will give you a transparent look at the real advantages of working with a staffing agency, along with key factors to consider when deciding if it’s the right choice for your business. Let’s get into it!

What Is a Staffing Agency and How Does It Work?

A staffing agency is a specialized recruitment firm that helps businesses find, vet, and place employees in different types of roles, including:

• Temporary hires – Short-term workers for seasonal demand or project-based needs.
• Temp-to-hire candidates – Employees that start on a contract basis before transitioning to full-time.
• Direct-hire placements – Full-time employees sourced and screened by the agency.

How the Process Works

1. Your business defines hiring needs (temporary, contract-to-hire, or direct placement).
2. The staffing agency sources and pre-screens candidates from its talent network.
3. You review and interview the top candidates presented by the agency.
4. For temporary roles, the staffing agency handles payroll, benefits, and compliance.
5. You manage the employee’s day-to-day work and performance.

So if you’re asking, “why use a staffing agency?” The answer lies in faster hiring, access to pre-vetted candidates, and reduced HR burdens—all while lowering the risks of making a costly hiring mistake.

Related: Understanding the 9 Different Types of Staffing Agencies

---

The Real Advantages of Using a Staffing Agency

1. Hire Faster Without Sacrificing Quality

A prolonged hiring process can slow down operations and cost businesses thousands in lost productivity. The average time to fill in 2024 was 41 days, but a staffing agency can reduce this to just a few weeks or even days by tapping into a pre-screened talent pool. This means you can fill urgent roles quickly, maintain efficiency, and keep projects on track.

• Reduced downtime → Prevent productivity gaps and delays.
• Avoid lost revenue → Quickly secure qualified employees to meet business demands.

Example: A manufacturing company facing a production surge fills 10 machine operator roles within a week by using a staffing agency instead of struggling with a lengthy hiring process, ensuring production stays on schedule.

2. Gain Access to a Larger and More Qualified Talent Pool

The best candidates aren’t always actively applying—many are passive job seekers who will only consider new roles when approached by a recruiter. Staffing agencies have wide-reaching talent networks and know how to engage top talent, including those with highly specialized skills.

• Pre-vetted candidate database → Instant access to top talent without waiting for applications.
• Proactive recruiting → Agencies actively source candidates instead of relying on job board postings.

Example: An aerospace company needing an avionics engineer uses a staffing agency to quickly source a highly specialized expert, ensuring critical projects stay on track.

3. Reduce Hiring Costs and Improve ROI

A bad hire can cost a company up to 30% of the employee’s salary, not to mention the lost time and resources spent on recruitment. Staffing agencies help reduce hiring costs by handling job postings, screening, and onboarding, while also lowering turnover risks and overtime expenses.

• No job board fees or HR software costs → The agency handles sourcing and screening.
• Lower overtime costs → Temporary staff support full-time employees during peak periods.
• Minimize costly turnover → Agencies ensure better candidate matching to reduce employee churn.

Example: A manufacturing firm saves thousands by hiring temporary workers for six-month contracts instead of committing to long-term payroll costs.

4. Reduce Hiring Risks with Temp-to-Hire Flexibility

Hiring the wrong candidate can be expensive and disruptive. Temp-to-hire roles give businesses a trial period to evaluate employees before making a long-term commitment. This ensures the right cultural fit, work ethic, and skill level before transitioning a temporary worker into a permanent role.

• Minimize hiring risks → Test candidates in real work scenarios before offering full-time employment.
• Seamless transition to full-time → Easily convert top-performing temps into permanent employees.

Example: A logistics company hires a warehouse supervisor on a 90-day contract, confirming their skills and cultural fit before extending a full-time offer.

Related: Contract Staffing & Temp-to-Hire Services

5. Improve Employee Retention and Productivity

Overworked employees are more likely to burn out, disengage, and leave, costing companies time and money. Staffing agencies help businesses balance workloads, reduce turnover, and find candidates who align with long-term business goals—leading to a happier, more productive workforce.

• Reduce burnout → Temporary staff relieve full-time employees during peak workloads.
• Increase retention → Agencies match candidates based on skills, goals, and company culture.

Example: An HR department reduces employee burnout by hiring temporary HR specialists during peak hiring seasons, ensuring the core team stays productive and focused.

---

Considerations When Using a Staffing Agency (And How to Overcome Them)

While staffing agencies provide significant advantages, businesses should carefully evaluate potential challenges before deciding if outsourcing recruitment is the right solution. Below, we break down key considerations and how to navigate them effectively.

1. The Cost of Staffing Fees vs. Long-Term Hiring Savings

One of the biggest concerns about staffing agencies is cost. Agencies charge placement fees for direct hires, typically ranging from 15% to 30% of the employee’s annual salary. For temporary workers, businesses pay a markup of 20% to 80% on hourly wages to cover recruiting, payroll, and administrative expenses.

At first glance, these fees may seem high, but the hidden costs of in-house hiring can be even greater. A bad hire can cost $15,000+ in lost productivity, training, and rehiring. Additionally, unfilled positions create bottlenecks, increase overtime costs, and slow business growth.

How to Overcome It:

• Compare staffing fees to the cost of an unfilled role, including lost revenue, overtime expenses, and recruitment costs.
• Work with an agency that offers flexible pricing models to fit your hiring needs and budget.
• Factor in long-term ROI, as hiring the right candidate from the start reduces turnover and additional hiring costs.

2. Ensuring the Right Cultural Fit

Finding employees who align with your company culture is just as important as finding those with the right skills. Employees who struggle to integrate into the work environment can negatively impact team morale, productivity, and retention.

This is particularly critical for client-facing roles, leadership positions, and highly collaborative teams. Some staffing agencies focus primarily on technical skills rather than cultural fit, which can lead to mismatches that result in high turnover.

How to Overcome It:

• Choose a staffing agency that prioritizes cultural fit, not just technical skills and experience.
• Communicate your company values, team dynamics, and leadership style to the agency.
• Request video introductions, recorded interviews, or behavioral assessments to evaluate candidates beyond their resumes.
• Use temp-to-hire options to assess candidates in a real work environment before committing to a full-time hire.

Related: 8 Critical Questions to Ask a Recruiting Agency

3. Limited Control Over the Hiring Process

When working with a staffing agency, businesses rely on recruiters to source, screen, and select candidates. While this saves time, it also means less direct involvement in the early hiring stages. If a staffing agency doesn’t fully understand a company’s needs, it may present candidates who lack key soft skills, industry-specific knowledge, or long-term potential.

How to Overcome It:

• Maintain clear and regular communication with your staffing agency throughout the process.
• Provide detailed job requirements and define must-have qualifications from the start.
• Request candidate summaries, recruiter insights, and additional screening measures to ensure the right fit.
• Work with an agency that understands your industry to avoid mismatches in skills or expectations.

4. Dependence on Temporary Workers

Over-reliance on temporary staffing can create workforce instability, especially in roles that require deep company knowledge, long-term client relationships, or strategic decision-making. While temporary workers provide flexibility, frequent turnover can disrupt continuity and increase training cycles.

How to Overcome It:

• Use temporary workers strategically, reserving them for seasonal needs, short-term projects, or workload surges.
• Identify roles that should remain permanent to ensure long-term stability.
• Consider temp-to-hire arrangements for roles where long-term retention is a priority.
• Create structured onboarding and training processes for temporary workers to maintain consistency.

5. Finding the Right Staffing Partner

Not all staffing agencies provide the same level of service and expertise. Some prioritize high-volume placements over long-term success, resulting in mismatched candidates and high turnover rates. Others may lack industry experience, making it harder to find specialized talent.

A poor staffing partner can result in wasted time, costly hiring mistakes, and frustration for both employers and candidates.

How to Overcome It:

• Choose a staffing agency with expertise in your industry to ensure they understand your hiring needs.
• Look for agencies with high retention rates, strong client testimonials, and proven success metrics.
• Review case studies and client references to gauge the agency’s track record in delivering quality hires.
• Ensure the agency offers multiple hiring models (temporary, contract-to-hire, direct-hire) for flexibility.

---

Conclusion: Why Use a Staffing Agency?

Hiring the right employees is critical but time-consuming and costly. Why use a staffing agency? Faster hiring, top talent, lower risks, and flexible workforce solutions. Whether you need quick placements, lower turnover, or scalable hiring, the right staffing partner makes all the difference.

Struggling to hire? We’ve spent 65+ years making it easy. Contact Amtec today